Attachment, Sustainability, and Control over Natural Resources

  • Laura Lo Coco University of Hertfordshire
  • Fabian Schuppert University of Potsdam

Abstract

In this paper, we discuss Armstrong’s account of attachment-based claims to natural resources, the kind of rights that follow from attachment-based claims, and the limits we should impose on such claims. We hope to clarify how and why attachment matters in the discourse on resource rights by presenting three challenges to Armstrong’s theory. First, we question the normative basis for certain attachment claims, by trying to distinguish more clearly between different kinds of attachment and other kinds of claims. Second, we highlight the need to supplement Armstrong’s account with a theory of how to weigh different attachment claims so as to establish the normative standing that different kinds of attachment claims should have. Third, we propose that sustainability must be a necessary requirement for making attachment claims to natural resources legitimate. Based on these three challenges and the solutions we propose, we argue that attachment claims are on the one hand narrower than Armstrong suggests, while on the other hand they can justify more far-reaching rights to control than Armstrong initially considers, because of the particular weight that certain attachment claims have.

References

Armstrong C (2017). Justice and Natural Resources. Oxford University Press.

Buchanan A (2004). Justice, Legitimacy, and Self-determination. Oxford University Press.

Catala, A (2017). Entry on Territorial Rights. Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy.

Carnor C (1985). Collective and Individual Duties to Protect the Environment. Journal of Applied Philosophy 2: 243-259.

European Commission (2013). Studies for carrying out the Common Fisheries Policy: Lot 3 Socio-economic dimensions in EU fisheries MARE/2011/07

Heinämäki L (2009). Protecting the Rights of Indigenous Peoples – Promoting the Sustainability of the Global Environment. International Community Law Review 11: 3-68.

Hiskes R (2009). The Human Right to a Green Future. Cambridge University Press.

Howitt R (2002). Rethinking resource management: Justice, sustainability and indigenous people. Routledge.

Kellert S et al (2010). Community natural resource management: promise, rhetoric, and reality. Society and Natural Resources 13: 705-715.

Kolers A (2012). Justice, Territory and Natural Resources. Political Studies 60(2): 269-286.

Kokers A (2009). Land, Conflict, and Justice. Cambridge University Press.

Melo-Escrihuela C (2008). Promoting ecological citizenship: rights, duties and political agency. ACME: An International E-Journal for Critical Geographies 7: 113-134.

Miller D (2012). Territorial Rights: Concept and Justification. Political Studies 60: 252-268.

Moore M (2014). Which people and what land? Territorial right-holders and attachment to territory. International Theory 6: 121-140.

Moore M (2015). A Political Theory of Territory. Oxford University Press.

Moore M (forthcoming). Who Should Own Natural Resources? Polity Press.

Odenthal K (1998). Die Umweltpflichtigkeit der Souveränität. Berlin: Duncker & Humblot.

Ostrom E (2000). Private and Common Property Rights. In: Bouckaert B and De Geest G (eds) Encyclopedia of Law and Economics, vol. II. Civil Law and Economics. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 332-79.

Regulation (EU) No 1380/2013 Common Fisheries Policy [2003] OJ L 354.

Schuppert F (2012). Reconsidering Resource Rights: The Case for a Basic Right to the Benefits of Life-Sustaining Ecosystem Services. Journal of Global Ethics 8(2/3): 215-225.

Schuppert F (2014). Beyond the National Resource Privilege: towards an International Court of the Environment, International Theory 6: 68-97.

Simmons AJ (2001). On the Territorial Rights of States. Philosophical Issues 11(2): 300-326.

Simmons AJ (2012). States’ Resource Rights: Locating the Limits. Unpublished manuscript available at http://territorynetwork.wordpress.com

Stilz A (2009). Why Do States Have Territorial Rights? International Theory 1(2): 185-213.

Stilz A (2011). Nations, States, and Territory. Ethics 121(3): 572-601.

Tauli-Corpuz V (2015). Report of the Special Rapporteur on the rights of indigenous peoples. United Nations General Assembly Human Rights Council Thirtieth Session, Agenda item 3 A/HRC/30/41 (6 August 2015).

Welchman J (2012). A defence of environmental stewardship. Environmental Values 21: 297-316.

Ypi L (2012) A Permissive Theory of Territorial Rights. European Journal of Philosophy 22(2): 288-312.

Published
2021-07-28