EU immigration, Welfare Rights and Populism: A Normative Appraisal of Welfare Populism

Abstract

Populists in the EU often call for restrictions on EU immigrants’ access to welfare rights. These calls are often demagogic and parochial. This paper aims to show what exactly is both distinct and problematic with these populist calls from a normative point of view while not necessarily reducible to demagogy and parochialism. The overall aim of the paper is not to argue that all populists call for such restrictions nor to claim that all calls for such restrictions are populist. The purpose of the paper is rather humble. It only aims to show that populist calls for restrictions on EU immigrants’ access to welfare rights are characterised by two normatively problematic arguments that target two different subsets of the citizenry: what I dub for the purpose of this paper the moralists and the immoralists. It is the way populists address these two subsets of the citizenry, as well as the fact that they could simultaneously appeal to the concerns of both groups, that makes populist approaches to welfare rights both conceptually distinct to other approaches as well as potentially politically appealing to a more diverse population of voters.

Author Biography

Dimitrios E. Efthymiou, Goethe University Frankfurt
Dimitrios Efthymiou is a postdoctoral research fellow at Goethe University in Frankfurt. He is principally interested in normative political theory and has a particular interest in its feasibility conditions and application to public policy. His current research project focuses on labour migration in the EU and its normative implications for the nature and scope of the welfare state. Other research interests include: the role of state responsibility in theories of international justice, especially in the case of the EU; the relationship between goods-oriented approaches and domination-based accounts of economic exploitation as well as  topics such as environmental justice and the relationship between equality and legitimacy. His current research is funded by Justitia Amplificata and the German Research Council.

References

Alternative Für Deutschland (2017) Manifesto for Germany (§9.2):

https://www.afd.de/wp-content/uploads/sites/111/2017/04/2017-04-12_afd-grundsatzprogramm-englisch_web.pdf

Aristotle (1984) “Nicomachean Ethics” in The complete works of Aristotle, ed. Barnes, Jonathan. Princeton: Princeton University Press,

Art D (2011). Inside the Radical Right : The Development of Anti-Immigrant Parties in Western Europe. New York, Cambridge University Press, 2011.

Arzheimer K (2009). "Contextual Factors and the Extreme Right Vote in Western Europe, 1980-2002." 53(2): 259-275.

Arzheimer K (2015). "The AfD: Finally a Successful Right-Wing Populist Eurosceptic Party for Germany?" West European Politics 38(3): 535-556.

Arzheimer K and Carter E. (2006). "Political opportunity structures and right-wing extremist party success." European Journal of Political Research 45(3): 419-443.

Anderson E (2013) The imperative of integration. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Anderson, The imperative for integration, Attribution Bias

Baldwin P 1990. The Politics of Social Solidarity: Class Bases of the European Welfare State. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

BBC 07.01.2014: Nigel Farage calls for five-year ban on migrant benefits.

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-25630036

BBC 04.03.2015: UKIP's Nigel Farage calls for immigration visa points system

https://www.bbc.com/news/av/uk-politics-31724979/ukip-s-nigel-farage-calls-for-immigration-visa-points-system

BBC 09.05.2017: Iain Duncan Smith: EU membership 'let in low-value, low-skilled people'

https://www.bbc.com/news/av/uk-politics-39852464/iain-duncan-smith-eu-membership-let-in-low-value-low-skilled-people

BBC 22.03.2017: Fury at eurozone chief Dijsselbloem's 'racist' remarks

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-39350113

BBC 13.05.2018: European rough sleepers illegally detained and deported

https://www.bbc.com/news/av/uk-44098042/european-rough-sleepers-illegally-detained-and-deported

BBC 20.06.2018: Brexit: Will a dividend help pay for increasing the NHS budget?

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-44523513

BBC 2019 28.01.2019: Inside Europe: Ten Years of Turmoil (Documentary, episode 1)

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b0c1rjkc

Bachrach P & Baratz M S (1962) Two faces of power. American political science review, 56(4), 947-952.

Badano, G. and A. Nuti (2018). "Under Pressure: Political Liberalism, the Rise of Unreasonableness, and the Complexity of Containment." Journal of Political Philosophy 26(2): 145-168.

Beitz C R (1999). Political theory and international relations. Princeton University Press.

Brighouse H & Swift A (2006) Equality, priority, and positional goods. Ethics, 116(3), 471-497.

Betz H G (1993). "The New Politics of Resentment: Radical Right-Wing Populist Parties in Western Europe." Comparative Politics 25(4): 413.

Betz H G and Johnson C (2004). "Against the current—stemming the tide: the nostalgic ideology of the contemporary radical populist right." Journal of Political Ideologies 9(3): 311-327.

Blake M and Smith P T (2015) "International Distributive Justice", The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Edward N. Zalta (ed.), URL = <https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2015/entries/international-justice/>.

Canovan M (2004) Populism for political theorists?. Journal of Political ideologies, 9(3), 241-252.

Cornelis I and Van Hiel A (2015). "Extreme-Right Voting in Western Europe: The Role of Social-Cultural and Antiegalitarian Attitudes." Political Psychology 36(6): 749-760.

Dahl R. A., & Dahl R. A. (1956). A preface to democratic theory (Vol. 115). University of Chicago Press.

Dahl R. A. (1958). A critique of the ruling elite model. American Political Science Review, 52(2), 463-469.

Dahlström, C. and A. Sundell (2012). "A losing gamble. How mainstream parties facilitate anti-immigrant party success." Electoral Studies 31(2): 353-363.

De Koster W, et al. (2013). "The new right and the welfare state: The electoral relevance of welfare chauvinism and welfare populism in the Netherlands." International Political Science Review 34(1): 3-20.

Derks A. (2006). "Populism and the Ambivalence of Egalitarianism. How Do the Underprivileged Reconcile a Right Wing Party Preference with Their Socio-Economic Attitudes?" 2(3).

Dustmann C, Frattini T and Halls C 2010. 'Assessing the Fiscal Costs and Benefits of A8 Migration to the UK*', Fiscal Studies, 31:1-41;

Dustmann C, Frattini, T and Preston I 2012. 'The Effect of Immigration along the Distribution of Wages', The Review of Economic Studies. 80(1), 145-173.

Dustmann C, and Frattini, T 2014. 'The Fiscal Effects of Immigration to the UK', The Economic Journal, 124(580), 593-643;

DW News 05.08.2013: Germany's pension system tricky for foreigners

https://www.dw.com/en/germanys-pension-system-tricky-for-foreigners/a-16996930

DW News 21.11.2017: Immer mehr wohnungslose EU-Ausländer

https://www.dw.com/de/immer-mehr-wohnungslose-eu-ausländer/a-41463862?fbclid=IwAR37TdvtfrtO1wo0lFmIVUAF6Kd9jkiMzrNEmq6oDsHXTlfGCh6BqIbj6bM

EU law: see Recitals 10, 16 and 21 in Directive 2004/38.

ECJ Case law:

‘Dano’, Case C 333/13, Judgement of 11th November of 2014; ‘Alimanovic’, Case C 67/14, Judgement of 15th September 2015; ‘Garcia-Nieto’, Case C-299/14, Judgement of 25 February 2016; ‘Grzelczyk’, Case C-184/99, Judgement of 20 September 2001; ‘Collins’, Case C-138/02, Judgement of 23 March 2004; ‘Brey’, Case C-140/12, Judgement of 19 September 2013.

Fine S & Sangiovanni A (2015) “Immigration” in Moellendorf, D., & Widdows, H. (Eds.). (2015). The Routledge handbook of global ethics. Routledge.

Forst R (2017) Normativity and power: Analyzing social orders of justification. Oxford University Press.

France24 News: Bannon says EU integration 'dead' after parliament election

https://www.france24.com/en/20190527-bannon-says-eu-integration-dead-after-parliament-election

Givens T E (2005). Voting radical right in Western Europe. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Guardian News 10.11.2015: EU migrants claiming benefits: questions the government must answer

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/datablog/2015/nov/10/eu-migrants-claiming-benefits-questions-the-government-must-answer

Goldman A H (1982) ‘The Moral Significance of National Boundaries’, in Peter A. French, Theodore E. Uehling, Howard K. Wettstein (eds), Midwest Studies in Philosophy, Volume VII Social and Political Philosophy (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press), pp. 437–53.

Jackson B (2014) The political thought of Scottish nationalism. The Political Quarterly 85(1): 50–56.

Kaltwasser CR (2014) The responses of populism to Dahl’s democratic dilemmas. Political Studies 62(3): 470–487.

Kennan G F (1985) ‘Morality and Foreign Policy’ Foreign Affairs, 64/2: 205–18.

Kitschelt, H. (2007). "Growth and Persistence of the Radical Right in Postindustrial Democracies: Advances and Challenges in Comparative Research." West European Politics 30(5): 1176-1206.

Kitschelt H and McGann AJ (1995) The radical right in Western Europe : a comparative analysis. Ann Arbor, University of Michigan Press.

Kymlicka W (2006) Liberal nationalism and cosmopolitan justice. In Another cosmopolitanism, pp.128-144.

Lefkofridi Z & Michel E (2014). Exclusive solidarity? Radical right parties and the welfare state. Radical Right Parties and the Welfare State (December 2014). Robert Schuman Centre for Advanced Studies Research Paper, (2014/120).

Laclau L (2005) On Populist Reason. London: Verso.

Le Pen M (2016) After Brexit, the People’s spring is inevitable. New York Times, 28 June 2016. Available at: http://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/28/opinion/marine-le-pen-afterbrexit-the-peoples-spring-is-inevitable.html?smid¼fb-nytimes&smtyp¼cur&_r¼5, (accessed 29 June 2016).

Michel E (2017) Welfare politics and the radical right : the relevance of welfare politics for the radical right’s success in Western Europe (EUI PhD Thesis) http://hdl.handle.net/1814/46384

Mills CW & Wolfe A (2000) The power elite (Vol. 20). Oxford University Press.

Migration Observatory Report (02.05.2016): UK Government on Tax-credits:

https://migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/reports/eu-migration-welfare-benefits-and-eu-membership/

Miller D (2000) Citizenship and national identity. Cambridge: CUP.

Miller D (2009) Democracy’s domain. Philosophy and Public Affairs 37(3): 201–228.

Miller D (2016) Strangers in our midst. Harvard University Press.

Mouffe C (2018) For a left populism. London: Verso.

Mudde C (2004) The populist zeitgeist. Government and Opposition 39(4): 542–564.

Mudde C (2007) Populist radical right parties in Europe. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Mudde C (2017) The Populist Radical Right : A Reader. New York, Routledge.

Mudde C (2017) An ideational approach. In The Oxford handbook of populism

Mudde C and Kaltwasser CR 2013. “Exclusionary vs. inclusionary populism: comparing contemporary Europe and Latin America,” Government and Opposition, 48(2): 147–74.

Mudde C & Kaltwasser, C. R. (2013). Populism. In The Oxford handbook of political ideologies.

Mudde C Why Copying the Populist Right isn’t going to save the left

https://www.theguardian.com/news/2019/may/14/why-copying-the-populist-right-isnt-going-to-save-the-left

Mudde C The far right may not have cleaned up, but its influence now dominates Europe

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/may/28/far-right-european-elections-eu-politics

Mudde C and Kaltwasser CR (2013) Exclusionary vs. inclusionary populism: Comparing contemporary Europe and Latin America. Government and Opposition 48(2): 147–174.

Müller JW (2014) ‘The people must be extracted from within the people’: Reflections on populism. Constellations 21(4): 483–493.

Müller J W (2017) What is populism?. Penguin UK.

Nagel T (2005) The problem of global justice. Philosophy & public affairs, 33(2), 113-147.

OECD Country Policy Descriptions: https://www.oecd.org/els/soc/benefits-and-wages-country-specific-information.htm

Piketty T (2018). "Brahmin Left vs Merchant Right: Rising Inequality and the Changing Structure of Political Conflict." WID. world Working Paper 7.

Rathgeb P (2019) Makers against Takers: The Socio-Economic Ideology and Policy of Austria's Radical Right (working paper).

Rawls J (2001) The law of peoples: with" The idea of public reason revisited". Harvard University Press.

Rydgren J. (2013). Class politics and the radical right. London ; New York, Routledge.

Rydgren J et al. (2018). The Radical Right in the United Kingdom, Oxford University Press.

Rydgren J and Kitschelt H (2018). Party Systems and Radical Right-Wing Parties, Oxford University Press.

Rydgren J et. al. (2018). The Oxford handbook of the radical right. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Sangiovanni A (2017) “Non-discrimination, in-work benefits, and free movement in the EU.” European Journal of Political Theory, 16(2), 143-163.Sangiovanni, On Facts about EU immigration

Stanley B (2008). The thin ideology of populism. Journal of political ideologies, 13(1), 95-110.

Schumacher G and Van Kersbergen K (2016). "Do mainstream parties adapt to the welfare chauvinism of populist parties?" Party Politics 22(3): 300-312.

Swank D (2003) "Globalization, the welfare state and right-wing populism in Western Europe." 1(2): 215-245.

The Sun, 14.05.2018 : Rough Justice: EU rough sleepers to get hundreds of thousands of pounds in taxpayer-funded compensation after they were illegally booted out of the UK.

https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/6281141/eu-rough-sleepers-will-get-hundreds-of-thousands-of-pounds-in-tax-payer-funded-compensation-after-they-were-illegally-booted-out-of-the-uk/

Tilly C (1998). Durable inequality. Univ of California Press.

Urbinati N (2015) A revolt against intermediary bodies. Constellations 22(4): 477–486.

Urbinati N (2019) ‘Political Theory of Populism,’ Annual Review of Political Science, 22:1, 111-127.

Urbinati N (2019) Me the People: How Populism Transforms Democracy. Harvard University Press.

UK Government: Eligibility to Jobseeker’s Allowance:

https://www.gov.uk/jobseekers-allowance/eligibility

Van Parijs P & Vanderborght Y (2017). Basic income: A radical proposal for a free society and a sane economy. Harvard University Press.

Walzer M (1984) Spheres of Justice. Basic books.

White J and Ypi L (forthcoming) The politics of peoplehood. Political Theory.

Wright E O (2015). Understanding class. Verso Books.

Wolkenstein F (2015) What can we hold against populism? Philosophy & Social Criticism, 41(2), 111–129.

Wolkenstein F (2016) Populism, liberal democracy and the ethics of peoplehood. European Journal of Political Theory.

Published
2020-11-15